At some point in every capital project update, someone asks how much contingency is left. The answer is usually a single figure: the contingency budget, minus the changes approved so far.
That figure is easy to calculate and easy to audit. It is also a measure of what has been approved, not of what has been committed.
On an active project those are rarely the same. Work can be directed before it is priced, change requests can sit in review for weeks, and other changes are already expected but not yet submitted. Each of these draws on contingency before it appears in the approved total.
The gap between the two is where council can be surprised.
Two numbers that sound the same
It helps to separate two ideas that are often reported as one.
Named concept
The contingency balance
The contingency budget minus approved change orders and other approved draws. It answers the question “what have we formally spent?” It is what most project and financial reports show.
Named concept
The contingency position
The balance minus the exposure already in motion: directed work not yet priced, change requests under review, and changes the project team already expects. It answers the question “what is actually still available for the risks ahead?”
Large owners often report these separately. BC Hydro’s published contingency reporting for the Site C project, for example, distinguishes contingency released, contingency committed, the amount remaining, pending change notices still “in approval process,” and those that are “anticipated.” The same discipline is just as useful on a $10 million recreation centre as on a hydroelectric dam.
Where committed money hides
On most municipal projects, exposure that has not yet reached the approved total sits in four places.
Change directives
Under CCDC 2, the standard Canadian stipulated price contract, an owner can issue a Change Directive when a change within the general scope of the contract must proceed before the price is agreed. The contractor proceeds promptly, and the value is determined afterwards, largely on the contractor’s actual cost plus an allowance for overhead and profit. If the parties still cannot agree, the consultant determines the amount.
A change directive is a sensible tool. It keeps the work moving. But from the moment it is issued, the owner is committed to paying for that work, and the cost is usually not known until later. Until the directive is valued and converted to a change order, it often does not appear in the approved contingency draw at all.
Change requests under review
A contractor’s quotation for a proposed change, or a claim for extra work, may take weeks to review, negotiate and approve. Some will be rejected or reduced. But the realistic value of the ones likely to be approved is already exposure.
Changes the team already expects
Design clarifications in progress, conflicts found on site, and owner requests under discussion often have a likely cost long before anyone submits a price. Project teams usually know about these. They rarely show up in the reported balance.
Time-related costs
When a delivery or milestone moves, a change in contract time may follow, and with it time-related costs such as extended site overheads. Whether those costs are owed depends on cause and on the contract. The point is that schedule movement can carry a cost that is visible in one record well before it reaches the cost report.
An approved total tells you what has been decided. It does not tell you what has already been set in motion.
What the gap looks like
Consider a hypothetical project at the midpoint of construction.
| $10.0M contract, 55% complete | Amount | % of contract |
|---|---|---|
| Contingency budget | $800,000 | 8.0% |
| Approved change orders to date | −$310,000 | |
| Contingency balance (as usually reported) | $490,000 | 4.9% |
| Change directives issued, not yet valued (estimate) | −$145,000 | |
| Change requests under review (likely value) | −$95,000 | |
| Changes expected, not yet submitted (estimate) | −$60,000 | |
| Contingency position | $190,000 | 1.9% |
Nothing in this example is wrong. Every approved figure is accurate. The change directives were reasonable decisions to keep the job moving, and some of the pending requests will come in lower than requested. But a council told that $490,000 remains will make different decisions than one told that roughly $190,000 is genuinely uncommitted.
Why the gap opens
The gap is mostly a timing problem, not a reporting failure.
- Work is directed in the field in days. Valuation and approval take weeks or months.
- Change information lives in several places: the change log, the consultant’s directive register, site meeting minutes, correspondence and the contractor’s notices.
- Cost reports are prepared to a cutoff date and reach leadership and council some time later. Vantage Signal’s preliminary research on municipal capital reporting observed intervals of 29 to 64 days between a report’s information cutoff and its public review.
Contingency is also meant for a specific purpose. AACE International describes contingency as an amount added to an estimate for items, conditions or events whose state, occurrence or effect is uncertain and that experience shows will likely result, in aggregate, in additional cost. It typically excludes major scope changes. When contingency is drawn to fund scope additions, the reported balance falls, but so does the project’s cover for the risks it was set aside for. That is worth knowing alongside the number itself.
What stronger contingency reporting looks like
Stronger reporting does not require new systems or more paperwork from contractors. It means the owner team can show, at each update:
- the contingency balance and the contingency position, side by side
- a register of change directives, each with an estimated value, the date it was issued and the date pricing is due
- pending change requests with both the requested amount and a realistic expected value
- contingency used compared with percent complete, so the drawdown can be read against progress
- what each draw was for: unforeseen conditions, design changes or added scope
- schedule movements that may carry a cost, flagged before they reach the cost report
Questions worth asking at the next update
- How many change directives are open, and what is our estimate of their value?
- What is the realistic value of change requests still under review?
- What changes does the team already expect that have not yet been priced?
- How much of the contingency used so far went to added scope rather than unforeseen conditions?
- If every open item resolved at its expected value today, what would remain?
From balance to position
Vantage reads the change log, change directives, pending change requests, cost reports, schedules and meeting minutes together, and reports the contingency position alongside the balance. Each item links to the record it came from, and an analyst reviews it before it reaches the owner, so the CAO, finance and council see what is already committed, not only what has been approved.
It does not approve changes, value directives or replace the consultant’s determination. It gives the people who make those decisions a fuller view of the money while there is still time to act on it.
Because the contingency that matters is the contingency still available.
Sources
- 1. Clark Wilson LLP, “Changes in the Contract Work – CCDC 2’s General Condition 6.” https://www.cwilson.com/changes-in-the-contract-work-ccdc-2s-general-condition-6/
- 2. Manitoba Housing, “Change Directive (CCDC 2),” form FOR-36A. https://www.gov.mb.ca/asset_library/en/hah/docs/housing/FOR-36A_Change_Directive_CCDC2.pdf
- 3. BC Hydro, Site C Clean Energy Project, “Project Contingency Reporting Package,” as of June 30, 2017. https://www.sitecproject.com/sites/default/files/Site-C-June-Project-Contingency-Reporting-Package.pdf
- 4. AACE International, Recommended Practice 10S-90, “Cost Engineering Terminology,” definition of contingency. https://library.aacei.org/terminology/welcome.shtml
- 5. Sound Transit, “Contingency Management,” presentation to the System Expansion Committee, February 9, 2023. https://www.soundtransit.org/st_sharepoint/download/sites/PRDA/ActiveDocuments/Presentation%20-%20Contingency%20Management%2002-09-23.pdf
- 6. Vantage Signal, “Is the Project Still Where the Report Says It Is?” https://www.vantagecri.com/signal/data/information-currency-public-capital-projects